Last Updated Dec 2025

Top 10 Mattresses for Best Sleep

Doctor

Clinically Reviewed by Health Rating Experts

We receive referral fees for products purchased through links on this website. Full Advertising Disclosure The Health Rating is an independent, ad-supported comparison site. Products and services featured on our website are provided by companies that offer The Health Rating a form of payment. This compensation may affect where and in what order these products appear. The Health Rating uses a set of proprietary rules to determine how and where products are displayed. Please be aware that The Health Rating does not list every product or service available on the market.

Health Rating hero background image

Medical Advisory: Health Rating recommends hybrid mattresses for responsive support and cushioned comfort, making them ideal for a wide range of body types and sleep styles.

  • Rank
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • Starting
    Price
  • $649
  • $3,599
  • $2,899
  • $1,519
  • $1,599
  • $1,149
  • $2,975
  • $3,199
  • $1,299
  • $1,499
Health Rating Expert Scores
  • Health
    Rating
  • 9.8 / 10
  • 9.4 / 10
  • 8.9 / 10
  • 8.7 / 10
  • 8.5 / 10
  • 8.2 / 10
  • 8.1 / 10
  • 7.9 / 10
  • 7.6 / 10
  • 7.1 / 10
  • Sleep
    Rating
  • 9.9
  • 9.7
  • 9.0
  • 9.6
  • 8.1
  • 8.6
  • 8.8
  • 7.3
  • 6.9
  • 6.9
  • Pressure
    Relief
  • 9.7
  • 9.5
  • 9.1
  • 8.8
  • 9.2
  • 8.0
  • 7.9
  • 9.3
  • 8.1
  • 6.8
  • American
    Chiropractic
    Association
  • Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Endorsed
  • Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Not
    Endorsed
  • Fiberglass
    Free
Puffy Logo
  • Made in USA
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Sleep Trial
  • Balanced Hybrid design for overall comfort

  • Medium-plush firmness for joint support

  • Adapts to all sleep positions and body types

  • Fiberglass-free verified

  • Free shipping across USA

9.8 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $1,500

Includes Free Luxury Pillows + Sleep Masks

Use code: PUFFYHS


Dr. Shannon Seckel

Dr. Shannon Seckel

Pacific Northwest University of Health Sciences College of Osteopathic Medicine

Puffy Lux Hybrid's foam layers and support system are designed to reduce pressure on key joints like hips and shoulders. As a doctor, for my own body, the relief from aches and pains was immediate - an ideal balance of therapeutic support and cloudlike comfort.

9.8 OUT OF 10

Puffy's Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 9.8

  • Sleep Rating 9.9

  • Temperature Regulation 9.6

  • Motion Isolation 9.8

  • Value for Money 9.9

  • Pressure Relief 9.7

  • Materials Quality & Safety 9.9

  • Overall Comfort 9.8


Puffy is Recommended for:

  • Chronic back & joint pain

  • Superior cooling

  • Pressure relief

  • Hip & shoulder support

  • Motion isolation

  • Back support

  • All sleepers

  • Memory foam design

  • Medium feel

  • Enhanced cooling

  • Pressure-relieving support

  • 10-year warranty

9.4 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $300

Get Offer

9.4 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 9.6

  • Sleep Rating 9.7

  • Temperature Regulation 9.4

  • Motion Isolation 9.6

  • Value for Money 7.9

  • Pressure Relief 9.5

  • Materials Quality & Safety 9.7

  • Overall Comfort 9.6


Recommended for:

  • Back pain

  • Cooling

  • Pressure relief

  • Edge support

  • Motion isolation

  • Ceramic gel-infused foam design

  • Adjustable firmness

  • Temperature balancing

  • Sleep tracking

  • 15-year limited warranty

8.9 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $500

Get Offer

8.9 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 8.9

  • Sleep Rating 9.0

  • Temperature Regulation 8.7

  • Motion Isolation 8.8

  • Value for Money 9.2

  • Pressure Relief 9.1

  • Materials Quality & Safety 8.7

  • Overall Comfort 8.8


Recommended for:

  • Superior support

  • Cooling

  • Pressure relief

  • Couples

  • Hybrid design

  • Medium-plush feel

  • Breathable

  • Hip and shoulder pressure relief

  • Limited lifetime warranty

8.7 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE 20%

Get Offer

8.7 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 9.7

  • Sleep Rating 9.6

  • Temperature Regulation 8.4

  • Motion Isolation 8.0

  • Value for Money 7.8

  • Pressure Relief 8.8

  • Materials Quality & Safety 8.6

  • Overall Comfort 8.7


Recommended for:

  • Side sleepers

  • Zoned support

  • Pressure relief

  • Memory foam design

  • Soft feel

  • Responsive and supportive

  • Eco-friendly

  • 20-year warranty

8.5 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $500

Get Offer

8.5 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 8.4

  • Sleep Rating 8.1

  • Temperature Regulation 8.5

  • Motion Isolation 9.0

  • Value for Money 8.3

  • Pressure Relief 9.2

  • Materials Quality & Safety 8.4

  • Overall Comfort 8.1


Recommended for:

  • Breathability

  • Cooling

  • Targeted pressure relief

  • All sleepers

  • Hybrid design

  • Medium feel

  • Zoned lumbar support

  • Responsive and contouring

  • Limited lifetime warranty

8.2 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE 20%

Get Offer

8.2 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 8.5

  • Sleep Rating 8.6

  • Temperature Regulation 8.0

  • Motion Isolation 8.1

  • Value for Money 8.7

  • Pressure Relief 8.0

  • Materials Quality & Safety 7.9

  • Overall Comfort 7.8


Recommended for:

  • Side sleepers

  • Lower back pain

  • Motion isolation

  • Hip and shoulder pain

  • Gel-infused memory foam design

  • Adjustable firmness

  • Naturally breathable

  • Cooling, contouring support

  • Lifetime warranty

8.1 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE 15%

Get Offer

8.1 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 8.9

  • Sleep Rating 8.8

  • Temperature Regulation 7.7

  • Motion Isolation 7.4

  • Value for Money 7.3

  • Pressure Relief 7.9

  • Materials Quality & Safety 8.8

  • Overall Comfort 8.0


Recommended for:

  • Couples

  • Motion isolation

  • Pressure relief

  • Edge support

  • Hybrid design

  • Soft feel

  • Breathable

  • Contouring support

  • 10-year warranty

7.9 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $300

Get Offer

7.9 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 7.2

  • Sleep Rating 7.3

  • Temperature Regulation 9.1

  • Motion Isolation 8.2

  • Value for Money 6.9

  • Pressure Relief 9.3

  • Materials Quality & Safety 8.1

  • Overall Comfort 7.1


Recommended for:

  • Cooling

  • Edge support

  • Pressure relief

  • Hip & shoulder support

  • Memory foam design

  • Medium feel

  • Breathable, cooling cover

  • Responsive support

  • Lifetime warranty

7.6 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE $500

Get Offer

7.6 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 6.8

  • Sleep Rating 6.9

  • Temperature Regulation 7.4

  • Motion Isolation 8.8

  • Value for Money 8.5

  • Pressure Relief 8.1

  • Materials Quality & Safety 7.3

  • Overall Comfort 7.0


Recommended for:

  • Pressure relief

  • All sleepers

  • Motion isolation

  • Hybrid design

  • Medium feel

  • Temperature-regulating layer

  • Tri-zone lumbar support

  • Lifetime warranty

7.1 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
SCORE

SAVE 35%

Get Offer

7.1 OUT OF 10

Health Rating
Score Breakdown:

  • Back Support 6.8

  • Sleep Rating 6.9

  • Temperature Regulation 6.7

  • Motion Isolation 7.0

  • Value for Money 8.7

  • Pressure Relief 6.8

  • Materials Quality & Safety 7.2

  • Overall Comfort 6.7


Recommended for:

  • Back and hip pain

  • Cooling

  • Pressure relief

Frequently Asked Questions
About Mattresses

Our Mattress Review and Rating Process

We believe in complete transparency with our readers. A meaningful mattress review demands more than a simple comfort test. It requires a deep, objective analysis.

Through extensive, hands-on testing, we've developed a system that allows us to understand a bed from the inside out so that you can feel confident in your decision. Below are some of the key factors we look for.

  • Kettlebell on mattress representing durability testing

    Mattress Materials & Construction

    First and foremost, we're concerned with the materials used. A good mattress will have a thoughtful selection of quality materials that contribute to a healthy and comfortable sleep environment. Our analysis involves a full teardown of each product to verify its construction, from the density of the foams to the gauge of the coils. We prioritize mattresses built with certified, non-toxic materials, such as CertiPUR-US® foams and fiberglass-free fire retardants.

  • Person sleeping comfortably on mattress showing pressure relief

    Pressure Relief

    To objectively measure how well a mattress can alleviate stress on the body, we focus on its ability to distribute weight and contour to the body's natural curves. This is especially important for areas like the hips, shoulders, and lower back. A mattress that scores high in our pressure relief analysis provides a balance of comfort and support, which is critical for reducing aches and pains.

  • Thermal camera showing mattress temperature distribution

    Temperature Regulation

    Sleeping hot is a common issue that can disrupt deep sleep. We evaluate how well a mattress can regulate temperature by analyzing its materials and overall design. We prioritize mattresses with features known for breathability, such as open-cell foams, gel or copper infusions, and the natural airflow provided by the coil systems in hybrid models.

  • Person sitting on edge of bed with glass of water showing motion isolation

    Motion Isolation

    For those who share a bed, motion transfer can be a significant source of sleep disturbance. Our hands-on testing simulates real-world movements to gauge how much motion is transferred from one side of the bed to the other. A mattress with excellent motion isolation provides a calm, undisturbed sleep surface, ensuring a more peaceful night for both partners.